ANNOUNCEMENT

Worship with us @ Mountain of Fire Miracles Ministries, Budapest, Hungary Address: 1081 Bp II János Pál Pápa tér 2 (formerly Köztársaság tér) Direction: From Blaha, take tram 28, 28A, 37, 37A, 62...1 stop. From the traffic light cross to the other side... Or take Metro 4 & get off @ János Pál Pápa tér
Time of worship: Wednesdays @ 18:30 hr Sundays @ 10:30 hr
Tel: +36 203819155 or +36 202016005

God bless


Friday, 11 December 2015

FINANCE/AFRICA

Why president Zuma fired his finance minister
By Mzukisi Qobo

A fine technocrat who did not wear his position on his sleeve, and known for tapping into his soft power of persuasion, Nhlanhla Nene has now been shunted out of South Africa’s National Treasury. The man who was South Africa’s Finance Minister has been forced to make way for an obscure politician, David van Rooyen, who was on the backbenches of parliament.


There are very few things that are surprising about South African politics, in particular the president’s decisions. In 2012 a Constitutional Court judgment described a key appointment President Jacob Zuma had made in the justice ministry as “irrational”. Since then irrationality and Zuma have become synonymous.

One of the difficulties in analysing developments in South Africa is that political decision-making does not fit any neat theory in political science. The president is unpredictable. His policy thinking is woolly.

Zuma’s sense of South Africa’s political and economic vision is shrouded in destructive ambiguity. This helps him to consolidate his authority in the ruling party, but it weakens the country’s institutions.

Nene’s legacy
The decision to fire Nene as Finance Minister has shocked many. It immediately sent ripples through the financial markets. In understanding the president’s frame of mind it is important to remember that Zuma is not an institutionalist leader whose primary concern is to defend the country’s institutions and safeguard its economic well-being. It is a leap of faith to believe that a leader who has several times shown his inability to pronounce a figure of less than R1 billion can preside over a R4 trillion economy and still appreciate its complexity.

Nene’s appointment as finance minister in 2014 was quickly welcomed by international markets. His technocratic flare and understanding of the country’s complex economic challenges endeared him to political parties across the spectrum. Before his appointment he had been chairperson of the portfolio committee on finance and then deputy finance minister.

During his tenure he reinforced the importance of macro-economic stability and prudential fiscal management. He announced a cap on government spending and made a commitment to rein in the budget deficit which had grown to 4% of the GDP.

He spoke openly about the need to cap above-inflation wage increases for public sector workers, even though he later conceded to their higher demands. He continued along the path set by his predecessor Pravin Gordhan, eliminating wasteful government spending. This included spelling out limits to expenditure on flights, hotels and entertainment.

Why Nene was fired
The crux of Nene’s fall is not easy to decipher. But two factors seem to have driven the final nail into his professional coffin. The first has to do with his hard stance on the country’s state-owned airline, South African Airways. Nene challenged the board of the state-owned airline, led by Dudu Myeni, to reconsider its intended restructuring of a fleet arrangement with Airbus. The restructuring would have had fiscal implications with the government being forced to make good on its guarantees.

Second, it is apparent that Zuma found the National Treasury, and Nene in particular, a stumbling block to a nuclear deal the President is believed to have promised the Russians. It is estimated that the deal could cost as much as R1 trillion. Nene’s allocation of a mere R200m towards research for this programme must have been seen as an insult by Zuma’s cronies and insiders.

Zuma believes that this nuclear deal will be a magic bullet for South Africa’s urge to undertake industrialisation on a large scale, address energy deficits and create employment. He may turn out to be right on some of the outcomes, but the push to flout procurement rules and avoid accountability signifies a destruction of institutions.

The likely, and more menacing scenario, is deepening corruption. This is more so given Russia’s impoverished corporate governance culture. The nuclear deal, if implemented, could create a feeding trough on a gigantic scale for cadres and cronies while acting as a debt albatross for future generations.

At the heart of both the South African Airways saga and the nuclear deal is the failure by the country’s leadership to adhere to accountability and transparency mechanisms, especially the Public Finance Management Act, as well as to grasp the implications of irrational decision-making on the fiscus and the economy.

A bad omen for South Africa
The markets or economic actors are not familiar with Van Rooyen, Nene’s replacement at the helm of National Treasury. He clearly is someone Zuma considers malleable. The appointment itself was handled clumsily with no forewarning to the markets. This was a serious mistake given the strategic importance of National Treasury. The department stands at the nexus between the domestic economy and global markets.

What we can draw from these changes is that National Treasury has now lost its place of pride as a premier economic nerve centre for government. The cavalier manner in which Zuma has treated this crucial institution will have implications for the economy.

Investor confidence will be negatively affected, and trust in the ability of the ruling party to provide economic leadership severely eroded. Further, there will be a heightened sense of political risk, making it even harder to convince investors about South Africa’s profile as an investment destination.

The public debt, which is already hovering close to 50% of the GDP, will balloon, with implications for fiscal sustainability in the future. Delivery of quality public services, public sector wages, and ability to modernise infrastructure will suffer further.

To hope for faster economic growth and job creation under such a scenario is a pipe dream.
What will get South Africa out of the quagmire is a revolt within the ruling African National Congress to challenge Zuma to explain himself and to provide a credible plan to reform and manage the economy.

Second, the local government elections due to be held in early 2016 should be a platform to rebuke government for its shambolic management of the economy.

Editor’s note:
Mzukisi Qobo, Associate Professor at the Pan African Institute, University of Johannesburg

This article was originally published on The Conversation. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

COPYRIGHT

COVER STORY

MY SMALL VOICE COLUMN

MY SMALL VOICE COLUMN
Odd jobs stacked against EU immigrants

COLUMN: MY SMALLVOICE

COLUMN: MY SMALLVOICE
TV2's false report about Nigerians in Hungary

MY SMALL VOICE

MY SMALL VOICE
Remembering a true prophet, Bob Marley...click on photo to read

MY SMALL VOICE

MY SMALL VOICE
Subsidising fraud & lies & blood...click on photo to read

MY SMALL VOICE:

MY SMALL VOICE:
Libya: The return of colonialist bondage.

Editor's Mail

Love the article on Gaddafi
We must rise above tribalism & divide & rule of the colonialist who stole & looted our treasure & planted their puppets to lord it over us..they alone can decide on whosoever is performing & the one that is corrupt..but the most corrupt nations are the western countries that plunder the resources of other nations & make them poorer & aid the rulers to steal & keep such ill gotten wealth in their country..yemen,syria etc have killed more than gadhafi but its not A̷̷̴ good investment for the west(this is laughable)because oil is not in these countries..when obasanjo annihilated the odi people in rivers state, they looked away because its in their favour & interest..one day! Samosa Iyoha

Hello from
Johannesburg
I was amazed to find a website for Africans in Hungary.
Looks like you have quite a community there. Here in SA we have some three million Zimbabweans living in exile and not much sign of going home ... but in Hungary??? Hope to meet you on one of my trips to Europe; was in Steirmark Austria near the Hungarian border earlier this month. Every good wish for 2011. Geoff in Jo'burg

I'm impressed by
ANH work but...
Interesting interview...
I think from what have been said, the Nigerian embassy here seem to be more concern about its nationals than we are for ourselves. Our complete disregard for the laws of Hungary isn't going to help Nigeria's image or going to promote what the Embassy is trying to showcase. So if the journalists could zoom-in more focus on Nigerians living, working and studying here in Hungary than scrutinizing the embassy and its every move, i think it would be of tremendous help to the embassy serving its nationals better and create more awareness about where we live . Taking the issues of illicit drugs and forged documents as typical examples.. there are so many cases of Nigerians been involved. But i am yet to read of it in e.news. So i think if only you and your journalists could write more about it and follow up on the stories i think it will make our nationals more aware of what to expect. I wouldn't say i am not impressed with your work but you need to be more of a two way street rather than a one way street . Keep up the good work... Sylvia

My comment to the interview with his excellency Mr. Adedotun Adenrele Adepoju CDA a.i--

He is an intelligent man. He spoke well on the issues! Thanks to Mr Hakeem Babalola for the interview it contains some expedient information.. B.Ayo Adams click to read editor's mail
Watch live streaming video from saharareporters at livestream.com

Daily Calendar

Popular Posts

Our Blog List